Chapter 13 bankruptcy can be a lifeline if you’re trying to save your home, protect your car, or reorganize overwhelming debt. It offers structure, relief, and a pathway to long-term stability.
But many repayment plans never make it to discharge. The court may confirm a plan, but that’s only the starting line. Staying in the plan for three to five years is the real challenge.
You’re not alone if you’ve heard stories of plans falling apart. Even trustees in California, including longtime trustee Larry Simons, regularly see cases collapse for avoidable reasons. When you understand the common pitfalls, you can take steps to avoid them, and a seasoned bankruptcy attorney can help you navigate the process with far fewer surprises.
Income Changes That Throw Everything Off Track
A Chapter 13 plan only works when your income stays consistent. The court expects you to make monthly payments, often on a tight schedule and without grace periods. When income drops even slightly you may fall behind quickly.
Job loss, reduced hours, industry slowdowns, medical leave, caregiving responsibilities, or even losing overtime can derail your plan. Many Californians start Chapter 13 with stable employment only to face unexpected income shifts later. Once you miss payments, trustees may file a motion to dismiss the case, and you lose the protection you fought to secure.
You can avoid this with early communication. If your income changes, your attorney can help modify your plan, request temporary payment relief, or restructure debts before the situation spirals. The biggest mistake people make is waiting too long to ask for help.
Budgeting Rules That Leave No Room for Real Life
When the court confirms your Chapter 13 plan, it imposes strict budgeting expectations. Trustees often cut expenses that feel necessary to you but don’t meet the court’s definition of reasonable. That means you may walk into a plan with almost no breathing room.
Real life isn’t predictable. A plan may work on paper but fail in practice when you face everyday expenses the budget didn’t account for. Even a minor disruption—your utility bill spikes, your phone breaks, your car needs maintenance—can throw off your ability to make plan payments.
As trustee Larry Simons has noted in various public forums, plans often fail because they weren’t realistic from the start. Working with an attorney who understands trustee expectations in California helps you build a budget that actually matches how you live. You need a plan that reflects real-world numbers, not wishful thinking.
Unplanned Emergencies Push You Behind
Even the most carefully built plan can collapse when unexpected emergencies hit. Medical bills, car accidents, home repairs, family crises, and natural disasters can overwhelm the narrow margins allowed in a typical Chapter 13 budget. The court doesn’t automatically pause your payments when life happens, and trustees move quickly when a plan becomes delinquent.
Many Californians believe they can simply catch up later, but that window closes fast. Once you’re more than a month behind, keeping the case alive becomes much harder. If the court dismisses your bankruptcy, you lose your automatic stay putting you at risk of foreclosure, repossession, and renewed creditor collection efforts.
Your attorney can request payment suspensions, modify your plan, or reallocate funds when emergencies arise. Those options disappear quickly if you wait until the trustee files a dismissal motion. The key is taking action the moment your circumstances change.
Misunderstanding What the Plan Actually Requires
Chapter 13 isn’t just one monthly payment. Many people don’t realize they must also keep up with ongoing expenses like mortgage payments, car insurance, HOA dues, property taxes, and child support. Missing any of these can cause your plan to fail even if you’re making trustee payments on time.
Another common issue is not understanding how tax returns and refunds factor into the plan. In many cases, the trustee requires your tax refunds during the three- to five-year period. When people spend those refunds without authorization, the case can unravel quickly.
California trustees also expect timely submission of documents, updated financial information, insurance proof, and notices of any major changes. Falling behind on paperwork has sunk more plans than most people realize.
An attorney helps you track these obligations so nothing slips through the cracks. Without that guidance, the process can feel like a maze.
Starting With the Wrong Chapter
A surprising number of failed plans began with a simple misunderstanding: Chapter 13 wasn’t the right choice in the first place.
Some people file Chapter 13 to stop a foreclosure, prevent a repossession, or deal with tax debt but never needed the long repayment structure. Others choose Chapter 13 because they make too much money for Chapter 7, not realizing that allowable expenses might still qualify them for Chapter 7 relief. Still others are pushed into Chapter 13 by creditors or pressure from credit-repair services.
When you choose the wrong chapter, the entire structure works against you. The plan may require payments you can’t sustain, or it may offer benefits you don’t need. Many plans fail simply because they weren’t the right solution from the start.
A knowledgeable attorney evaluates your goals, income, assets, and debt types to help determine if Chapter 13 is truly the best path or if another strategy gives you a better chance at long-term success.
Protect Your Future With the Right Support
A Chapter 13 repayment plan can protect your home, your car, and your financial future, but only if the plan survives long enough to reach discharge. Income changes, strict budgets, emergencies, and misunderstandings can all knock you off course. The right legal guidance helps you anticipate these challenges and stay ahead of them.
If you’re considering Chapter 13 or struggling to keep an existing plan on track, Janus Law is here to help. We’ll review your situation, explain your options, and guide you through the process with the support you need.
Contact Janus Law right now to get started.
- Chapter 13 Pitfalls: Why Many Repayment Plans Fail Before Completion - December 4, 2025
- Life After Chapter 7: How to Rebuild Credit and Confidence - November 9, 2025
- How the 2025 Government Shutdown Is Affecting Californians and What You Can Do Now? - November 3, 2025
Schedule An Appointment
Talk to a Bankruptcy Attorney Right Now
Call Now to Schedule An Appointment
Other Tips
Life After Chapter 7: How to Rebuild Credit and Confidence
How the 2025 Government Shutdown Is Affecting Californians and What You Can Do Now?
